Baptism Gift Guide: Gift ideas for Baby, Godmothers, and Godfathers

Hi Everyone!

I hope you all are having a restful and relaxing weekend. Today we are going to talk about baptism -- one of the most exciting and important things to happen in a family! 

And baptism, which [the flood] prefigured, now saves you—not as a removal of dirt from the body, but as an appeal to God for a good conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ,” - 1 Peter 3:21.

This has been on my mind especially recently since we've already started planning our new baby's baptism. Call me crazy, but I like having baby baptized ASAP after their born, so we start talking to our priest and getting prepared before baby leaves the womb.  

To help you and your loved ones celebrate, I made a list of wonderful gift ideas for babies, Godmothers, and Godfathers. These are from my favorite artisans and small businesses... I hope you love them as much as I do!


Carseat/Stroller Pin from Relics By Rose. - These are so pretty and are definitely on my list for our own new babe.

Saint Goals Onesie Annunciation Designs  - We have this design in a t-shirt for my daughter and we love it! It's so incredibly soft.

Wooden Saint Toys from Saintly Heart  - These look so cute and I can't wait to add them to our own collection of saint dolls!

Baptism Gift Box from Pillar and Pearl  - Pillar and Pearl gift boxes are definitely on my dream list, they are so beautifully curated and this one for baby's baptism is no exception!

Baptism Art Print from Agnus Dei by Kelly  - Beautiful hand painted picture with a hand-lettered quote, perfect as a baptism gift.

“Guardian Angel Prayer” or "Jesus Loves Me" Art Print from Abundance of Grace Prints - I love Abundance of Grace's style and these prints would make a perfect additions to any nursery. 

Bandana Bib or Bonnet from Meadowcress Boutique

Saint Inspired Hair Bows from Mamas Little Loves Shop -  These bows are so cute and I love all of the different designs that she offers.

Catholic Baby Memory Book from Thy Olive Tree -  These keepsake books are not only super high quality, but really easy to use and easy to catch up in when you miss a few months of recording baby's developmental and faith based milestones. 

Rosary Teether from Be A Heart Designs -  These teethers are so cute and definitely on my list for new babe!


Personalized Baptism Bowl from Clarey Clayworks - This little dish is meant to be used by the priest as he pours water over your little one during their baptism and is a beautiful and special way to remember their entering into the Church.

Customizable Sacramental “Favorite Things” poster from Elizabeth Alice Studio - Similar to the posters that you see on the first day of school or on birthdays, this poster is specifically designed to be used alongside sacramental milestones to record the child's current favorite things and activities

Personalized Baptism Picture Frame from Burning Heart Crafts -  This frame is absolutely beautiful! It is custom wood burned with baby's name, baptism date and includes the image of a paschal candle with the current year. 

Personalized Holy Water Bottle from Burning Heart Crafts -  Perfect for bringing home some of that special holy water from baby's baptism.

Personalized Baptism Keepsake Print from Thy Olive Tree - This print makes a perfect baptism keepsake to hang in babies room to remind them of their initiation into the church!


Custom Rosary from Madonna Rose Designs - These beautiful custom rosaries would make a perfect gift for babies, godmothers or godfathers!

Teething Rosary from Chews Life - Our own teething rosary from Chews Life has been well loved through two kiddos so far, and I can't wait for this new baby to get it into his or her hands.  



Baptism Card from Annunciation Designs

Baptism Card from Thy Olive Tree

Personalized Baptism Card from Catholic Paper Goods 


Godmama Mug Cozy from The Cozy Wife - The Cozy Wife's mug cozies add a beautiful touch to your morning cup of coffee or tea!

Scrunchie or Pouch from Meadowcress Boutique

Godmama Gift Box from Pillar and Pearl Again, a beautifully curated box with gifts perfect for thanking to make your baby's godmother for their commitment and support as your raise your sweet babe in the faith.

Prayer Journal and Sticker Bundle or Prayer Card Bundle from Abundance of Grace Prints - I am always in need of a new journal and I really love having one specifically devoted to my time with God. These gifts are perfect for enhancing any godmama's daily prayer time.

Personalized Greeting Cards from Thy Olive Tree - With their classic and minimal design this gift is perfect for the godmother who loves to share her love through writing! 


Mug from Annunciation Designs - This mug is made by hand and perfect for enjoying a good cuppa in the morning.

Personalized Greeting Cards from Thy Olive Tree -  Perfect for godfathers who like to connect via snail mail, they have a beautiful monstrance design and would also make a great gift for your priest as well!  

Catholic Men’s Personal Care (beard balm, skincare) from Catholic Balm Co. - My favorite item from Catholic Balm Co. is their chrism scented beard balm, perfect to remind your baby's godfather of your baby's baptism day!

St. Michael Inspired Candle from Corda Candles I love Corda Candles I have one and have given several as gifts, they all smell absolutely wonderful and I think this St. Michael inspired candle called "Battle Cry" would make a perfect gift for a godfather.

Baptism is a meaningful event in a family, and I am so excited that these ideas will help you all celebrate such an exciting time.

Head over to our Instagram page for new content, and subscribe to our newsletter for new launches, deals, and giveaways.

Happy shopping!



Sold Out